I know that most of you want to actually watch the show before you have people like us tell you the winner, but then again you are here. Be prepared for a shocker tonight as Carly Smithson packs her bags for home. The bottom two was a complete shocker to me in all truth. Syesha Mercado and Carly Smithson should have been in the Top 4 not on the chopping block tonight. Brooke White forgot what she was singing and Jason Castro was a train wreck. Proves again that American Idol is not a talent contest but a beauty contest. I suggest you vote only for the dynamic duo of David's the rest of the way or you could see a Brooke Castro showdown...God help us all.

More